The Problem of Evil, Part 3

I took a creative writing class one time in grad school. Each week, the professor gave us a one-word prompt and we would write a short piece. We could write about anything we wanted, as long as it had something to do with that word. One week, the word was “web.” I started thinking about that word and it occurred to me that the circumstances of our lives resemble webs. Really big webs. Every little thing connects to every other, every decision, every conversation, every seeming coincidence. Even the bad things—the tragedies, heartbreaks, and even our worst failures. Somehow God weaves all of this together into His master plan. That’s what I want to wrestle with here. 

I have previously attempted to show that evil and suffering cannot be used to prove that the Christian worldview is logically incoherent. I have also proposed that the joy and wonder that our free will makes possible (particularly when fully realized in the eternal state) is a very likely reason why God decided that a universe with evil was worth it. Even so, the consideration of evil and suffering—especially the evil and suffering in our own experience—is still fraught with tension. Thinking about God as the sovereign “master Weaver” in relation to the evils of our world helps release some of that tension.

I have argued elsewhere that God knows every possible combination of states of affairs, including how free creatures could, and even would, act and react in every situation. Or, to put it a bit differently, God knows how things could and would go down in any and every imaginable permutation of the world. Armed with this knowledge, He has selected, or actualized, one that is optimal.

If you think about it, this could have huge implications for the problem of evil. God might have minimized, or mitigated, the amount of evil that His free creatures would have to suffer by selecting the world that He did. He also might have been able to repurpose as much of that evil as possible for good. This is similar to Leibniz’s idea that our world is the “best of all possible worlds.” In the face of our world’s great evils (especially the really horrendous ones) a claim such as this could seem ludicrous and even depressing, but I think these kinds of ideas are worth considering. Let me give you a hypothetical example to illustrate the sort of thing I’m thinking about.

Say you come down with a bad cold on Monday. On Tuesday, your good friend Jessica drops by your apartment with a care package with cookies, lemon-flavored lozenges, and of course, chicken soup. Unfortunately, Jessica isn’t careful about washing her hands afterwards, and a couple days later she comes down with the virus. On Friday, she goes to the doctor, who sends her to Walgreens to get some medicine.

Also on Friday, Christopher the pharmacy technician, who normally works Monday through Thursday, gets called into work due to an abnormally large influx of sick patients coming down with this virus, thereby sacrificing the day of lounging by the pool he had planned. Jessica and Christopher, both single, hit it off when Jessica gets to the front of the line.

Several months and pharmacy visits later, Jessica and Christopher exchange phone numbers and go out. Eventually, they marry and start a family. One hundred twenty years later, their great, great, great granddaughter discovers the cure for cancer. All of this happened because you came down with that nasty cold.

Okay maybe that seems a little far-fetched, but think about it. If God has knowledge of all contingencies, who’s to say He hasn’t arranged things thus that cause/effect chains like the one I just described aren’t in the works every single day? A child from the slums of a neighboring city is delivered from poverty because you stubbed your toe. A family of Bedouin nomads in Yemen comes to know Jesus because that relationship didn’t work out. It’s kind of like the movie Back to the Future, but a billion times more complicated. Most of the time, we can’t say for sure whether or not these sorts of things happen, but God’s foreknowledge and sovereignty totally makes it possible.

It’s also worth noting that suffering can serve redemptive purposes at a much more personal level. We all know this. No pain, no gain. If I don’t catch a cold every once in a while, my immune system will grow weak. If I don’t exercise, I will not be healthy. But these sufferings are light and hardly worth the designation. Real suffering can be redemptive too. Someone who has once endured the legal and emotional difficulties of a divorce is in a much better position to comfort others fighting similar battles. A leader who has tasted the bitter consequences of a moral failure will be less quick to compromise in the future. And wasn’t it Thomas Edison who spoke so winsomely about the value of getting something wrong over and over again before finally getting it right (in his case, discovering ten-thousand ways not to make a lightbulb)?

Redemptive suffering is especially pertinent to Christians because we know that our trials are oftentimes directed by the hand of God (Heb. 12:5-11). Suffering also takes us to new depths in our experience and understanding of God’s grace, and the peace which surpasses understanding (Phil. 4:7).

All that said, here me when I say this: Suffering is not inherently good. Death is not good. Divorce is not good. Sin is not good. These things are aberrations, and it would have been better if the need for the kinds of silver linings I’ve been mentioning didn’t exist in the first place. But as long as clouds crowd our skies, wouldn’t you rather the silver linings be there? I would. 

So how do all these things help us? Well, they help us to trust in God by giving us a glimpse into how He might operate in His sovereignty with respect to the troubles of the world. They give us confidence that our specific sufferings might have redemptive purposes, even if we can’t see what those are. They give us reason to have faith, that God-honoring and often difficult “assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen” (Heb. 11:1). Faith that our Heavenly Father is never surprised at the things that happen to us. Faith that at the end of the day—every day—He has every circumstance under His control. Faith that in the life to come, God will show us the web that connects all the failures and tragedies of our lives—the whole sprawling, awful, beautiful web—and over and over again we will be able to say, “I understand now.”

This may not be the best of all possible worlds. But it is the best way to the best of all possible worlds.